2
June 2003
'Toxic
tour' shows environmental justice in action
A 'toxic
tour' through scenic Welsh countryside showed the kind of pollution sources
many communities are exposed to - and the value of fighting back. Organised
by Women's Environmental Network, the bus tour skirted the North Wales
town of Wrexham. Sites visited included:
an incinerator burning BSE infected cattle, built across the road
from an abattoir, behind which is a beef farm. Despite lacking equipment
to control emissions of ash and particles and exploding on the day an
inspector visited, the incinerator was granted a licence to expand;1
a clinical waste incineration plant that was prosecuted by the Environment
Agency (EA) for routinely allowing a septic tank containing liquid waste
such as blood and body fluids to overflow into a tributary of the River
Dee;2
a synthetic chemical factory built before planning controls, that
dominates a small village and has a history of toxic gas escapes. After
two bad incidents and concerted community action, the company was prosecuted
and has now cleaned up its act, though its very presence and the highly
toxic chemicals stored on site still pose a considerable hazard to neighbouring
houses;3
an aluminium recycling plant that put in damping equipment after
an 18 month campaign by residents on the next-door housing estate who
couldn't sleep because of constant low-level vibrations. Their campaign
also led to requirements on low-level noise and vibrations being added
to regulations;4
a landfill waste site that has introduced a range of measures to
protect nearby residents and countryside from smell and pollution after
the 'bund' containing the site became unstable and started slipping into
the River Dee.5
Janet Williams, WEN-Wales Co-ordinator, put together the itinerary with
fellow-campaigners from Campaign for Rural Wales (CPRW) and Trefnu Cymedol
Cymru (TCC). She said: "The reason for taking this tour is not
to say Wrexham's a tip, it's not. We could actually take this tour in
any county in Wales - and probably many other parts of the UK - and point
out similar things.
"We want to show the different pressures for land-use, the way the
planning system is used, how environmental controls can be breached or
not enforced - and how communities can use these regulatory systems to
protect themselves and their environments."
Also on the route were rural roads suffering heavy traffic and various
examples of industrial plants sited worryingly close to housing or agricultural
land.
One highlight was the former site of a rubber factory which is now one
of the finest sites of biodiversity in the area after being left untouched
for more than five years. "Nature does fight back and fights back
very well," commented David Darlington, Chair of Wrexham CPRW.
The tour, attended by 40 people from the surrounding area and interested
groups, was followed by workshops on environmental law (run by Environmental
Law Foundation), the planning system (run by CPRW) and campaigning (run
by WEN).
ends
For more
information contact Liz Sutton, WEN Press & Information co-ordinator,
on 020 7481 9004 or Janet Williams, WEN-Wales co-ordinator,
on 01978 820819.
Notes
to editors
1. Animal Waste Services Ltd. Wrexham CPRW has evidence that the plant
lacks pollution abatement equipment. On the day it was visited by the
Planning Inspector presiding over a Public Inquiry in 1995, one of the
three burners exploded and the fire brigade was called. A licence was
granted later that year.
2. Eurocare Environmental Services Ltd runs a clinical waste incinerator
at Wrexham and several other waste facilities throughout the UK. It processes
most of the clinical waste from Wales, the West and North East. In February
2003 at Chester Crown Court it was fined £100,000 and ordered to
pay £114,818 costs after earlier pleading guilty to 10 charges relating
to the illegal storage and handling of clinical wastes at various sites
in England and Wales. The prosecution was brought by the EA. A report
in the April 2003 issue of 'Environment Action', published by the EA,
says: "A surveillance operation at Eurocare's Wrexham clinical waste
incinerator later revealed that liquid waste and washings from collecting
areas were being flushed into a septic tank under the cover of darkness.
The tank was found to overflow directly into the Red Wither Brook."
3. The Flexsys plant at Cefn Mawr, outside Wrexham, formerly operated
by Monsanto, was built in the 1920s, before current-day planning controls.
Some exhaust vents from the building are level with the bedroom windows
of adjacent houses. Because the village is in a valley, a blanket of cold
air sometimes traps in the toxic fumes, increasing the risk to residents
and workers. After a serious pollution incident in 1994 and a similar
one in 1995 Janet Williams and other affected villagers successfully completed
legal action against the factory and were awarded damages in two out of
court settlements. The COMAH (Control of Major Accident Hazards) restrictions
have since been brought in, but they have effectively placed a girdle
around the village, reducing the potential for development of new homes
or community facilities
4. TCC worked with families on the Pentre Maelor housing estate, affected
by noise and vibration from Hydro Aluminium Deeside Ltd's reprocessing
plant. After an 18 month campaign, during which they employed consultants
to measure the effects on different households and took their case - and
a BBC camera crew - to the company boss in New York, the company finally
installed damping equipment. Before the factory was built there were concerns
about its proximity to homes, but the company successfully argued that
it would have cost too much to build it further away. Chris Taylor, of
TCC, said: "Aluminium recycling is the right thing to do from an
environmental point of view but what is important is to make sure that
all the controls and regulations are in place."
5. In October 2000 the protective bund holding in one of the sides of
the Pen Y Bont landfill site at Cefn Mawr became unstable. The management
company, Shanks Waste Solutions, rebuilt the bund and installed groundwater
drainage, then monitored its stability weekly, then monthly, until earlier
this year when it was satisfied it was stable. The Environment Agency
was aware and checked the monitoring reports but did not take enforcement
action. The company has also started capping filled parts of the site
with plastic sheeting, to reduce smell and gas emissions and the site
is operated to a higher standard. However residents still report incidences
of odour on a regular basis.
6. WEN is a national membership charity that campaigns on environmental
and health issues from a women's perspective. It educates, informs and
empowers women and men who care about the environment.
7. WEN's health project is funded by the Community Fund. The day was also
supported by the European Social Fund.

|